Skip to content

Scissors

A scissor is when a finger extends to the far side of the keyboard at the same time as an adjacent longer finger flexes to the near side.

In colloquial use, scissors refer to a wide variety of motions that are considered uncomfortable, including some that do not fit the definition above. However, there is significant disagreement on which scissors are considered “bad.” The proportions of finger lengths vary from person to person as does each person’s ability to move each finger independently of the others.

Some examples of common scissors on QWERTY include:

Layer activators · Keysets

Layer activators

MOshiftwhen the next typed key is in shift_right
MOshiftwhen the next typed key is in shift_left

Keysets

shift_rightRight-hand keys except
shift_leftLeft-hand keys

Layouts Wiki analyzes keymaxx’s explicit press, hold-acquisition, and hold-release events. Scissors describe posture, so every event’s posture contains both its physical action keys and its sustained keys. Simultaneous scissor unigrams compare every unordered pair within one event’s posture. Bigrams compare every posture key at the first event with every posture key at the second, and skipgrams do the same at the first and third events. A steady hold participates for as long as that posture is maintained.

Headline totals such as HSB, FSB, HSS1, and FSS1 count each bigram or trigram at most once. Finger-pair breakdowns are involvement buckets; their sums may not partition the headline total when one n-gram contains multiple scissor pairs.

A scissor bigram is a bigram that creates a scissor motion between adjacent fingers. Scissors are classified by vertical row separation, with the shorter finger farther from the typist than the longer finger:

  • Half-scissor bigram (HSB): 1u vertical separation between the two keys
  • Full-scissor bigram (FSB): 2u vertical separation between the two keys

HSB%=100×weighted half-scissor bigram windowsweighted bigram windows\text{HSB}\% = 100 \times \frac{\text{weighted half-scissor bigram windows}}{\text{weighted bigram windows}}

FSB%=100×weighted full-scissor bigram windowsweighted bigram windows\text{FSB}\% = 100 \times \frac{\text{weighted full-scissor bigram windows}}{\text{weighted bigram windows}}

Scissors are considered uncomfortable due to the opposing motion of adjacent fingers, which can strain the tendons and reduce typing fluidity. Modern layouts often optimize to minimize scissors, though there is significant individual variation in scissor tolerance.

Different finger pairs have varying degrees of independence, affecting scissor severity:

  • Index-middle scissors: Generally most tolerable due to higher finger independence
  • Middle-ring scissors: Moderate severity
  • Ring-pinky scissors: Generally least tolerable due to lower finger independence

A scissor skipgram is a skipgram that creates a scissor motion between adjacent fingers. Like bigrams, these are classified by vertical row separation:

  • Half-scissor skipgram (HSS): 1u vertical separation between the two keys
  • Full-scissor skipgram (FSS): 2u vertical separation between the two keys

HSS1%=100×weighted matching half-scissor trigram windowsweighted trigram windows\text{HSS}_1\% = 100 \times \frac{\text{weighted matching half-scissor trigram windows}}{\text{weighted trigram windows}}

FSS1%=100×weighted matching full-scissor trigram windowsweighted trigram windows\text{FSS}_1\% = 100 \times \frac{\text{weighted matching full-scissor trigram windows}}{\text{weighted trigram windows}}

Both skipgram rates retain the complete original trigram population, even though classification examines only the endpoints. Finger and other filters do not shrink the denominator.

Scissor skipgrams capture uncomfortable patterns where the scissor motion happens with an intervening keypress, such as “c_r” in “car”. While less severe than direct scissors, they can still impact typing comfort and rhythm.